So Far So Good for Cannabis Legalization: Fewer Arrests, More Revenue


For cannabis law reform advocates, the extreme, dire warnings about cannabis legalization that come out of the mouths of prohibitionists are often laughable. From the ridiculous Reefer Madness days; to the lazy stoner stereotypes; to fear mongering about crime waves; to comparing the cannabis industry to Big Tobacco, we have heard hyperbole after hyperbole and falsehood after falsehood.

After years of suffering under the failed and harmful policy of cannabis prohibition across the nation, we have seen a dramatic change across our great country, starting with California legalizing medical cannabis in 1996. Over the last two decades, we have seen over half the country end cannabis prohibition in some form, with four states and our nation’s capital legalizing for all adults over the age of 21, starting with Colorado and Washington in 2012.

The Drug Policy Alliance has examined the data following cannabis legalization and the facts show that the predictions of prohibitionists have proven untrue. The sky hasn’t fallen, but across Colorado, Washington State, Oregon, Alaska and Washington, D.C., we have seen fewer arrests and more revenue. Hopefully, as several more states are poised to vote on legalization this November, voters will look at the actual experience of states that have ended prohibition and ignore the false Reefer Madness hysteria peddled by prohibitionists.

From the Drug Policy Alliance:

So Far, So Good: What We Know About Marijuana Legalization in Colorado, Washington, Alaska, Oregon, and Washington D.C.

New Report Finds Massive Drop in Marijuana Arrests, No Increase in Youth Marijuana Use, No Increase in Traffic Fatalities, and Major Fiscal Benefits in States With Legalized Marijuana

Tens of Thousands of People Spared from Harmful Marijuana Arrests and Collateral Consequences; $552 Million in Tax Revenue Raised in Colorado, Washington and Oregon

As Arizona, California, Maine, Massachusetts, and Nevada prepare to vote on marijuana legalization next month, all eyes are on the initial outcomes of those states that have already legalized marijuana. In 2012, Colorado and Washington became the first two U.S. states – and the first two jurisdictions in the world – to approve ending marijuana prohibition and legally regulating marijuana production, distribution and sales. In the 2014 election, Alaska and Oregon followed suit, while Washington D.C. passed a more limited measure that legalized possession and home cultivation of marijuana (but did not address its taxation and sale due to D.C. law).

A new report by the Drug Policy Alliance brings good news for the states considering legalization at the ballot on November 8, 2016, and the broader marijuana legalization movement. Since the adult possession of marijuana became legal, these states have benefitted from a dramatic decrease in marijuana arrests and convictions, as well as increased tax revenues. During the same period, these states did not experience increases in youth marijuana use or traffic fatalities.

“Marijuana prohibition has been a costly failure—to individuals, communities, and the entire country,” says Joy Haviland, staff attorney at the Drug Policy Alliance. “States that have chosen to legalize marijuana under state law should be praised for developing a smarter, more responsible approach to marijuana.”

The report’s key findings include:

  • Marijuana arrests have plummeted in the states that legalized marijuana, although disproportionate enforcement of marijuana crimes against black people continues.
  • Statewide surveys of youth in Colorado, Washington, Alaska, and Oregon found that there were no significant increases in youth marijuana use post-legalization.
  • Tax revenues in Colorado, Washington, and Oregon have all exceeded initial revenue estimates, totaling $552 million.
  • Legalization has not led to more dangerous road conditions, as traffic fatality rates have remained stable in Colorado, Washington, Alaska, and Oregon.

In Colorado, the total number of marijuana arrests decreased by 46 percent between 2012 and 2014, from 12,894 to 7,004.  In Washington,  the total number of low-level marijuana court filings fell by 98 percent from 6,879 in 2011 to 120 in 2013.  In Washington, D.C., marijuana arrests decreased 85 percent from 2014 to 2015, with possession arrests falling by 98 percent from 1,840 in 2014 to 32 in 2015. In Alaska marijuana charges and arrests in Alaska decreased by 59 percent between 2013 and 2015 even though retail sales of marijuana have not yet begun.  Marijuana arrests in Oregon declined by 50 percent from 2011 to 2014, from 4,223 arrests to 2,109 in 2014.

Nationally, there were 643,121 marijuana arrests in the U.S. in 2015, a decrease from 700,993 in 2014. Black and Latino people are arrested at vastly disproportionate rates, even though white people use and sell marijuana at similar rates. A marijuana arrest creates a permanent criminal record that can easily be found by employers, landlords, schools, credit agencies and banks. Additionally, the huge number of marijuana arrests every year usurps scarce law enforcement, criminal justice and treatment resources at enormous cost to taxpayers.

The Drug Policy Alliance and its electoral arm, Drug Policy Action, worked closely with local and national allies to draft each of this year’s initiatives, build coalitions, and raise funds. Voters in California, Massachusetts, Arizona, Nevada and Maine will vote on similar marijuana legalization initiatives next month.

“By shifting away from counterproductive marijuana arrests and focusing instead on public health, states that have legalized marijuana are better positioned to address the potential harms of marijuana use, while also diminishing many of the worst harms of the war on drugs,” added Haviland.

Anthony Johnson
About Anthony Johnson 159 Articles
Anthony Johnson, co-owner of Duff Johnson Consulting (DJC), served as the director of New Approach Oregon, the Political Action Committee responsible for Oregon's 2014 Measure 91 cannabis legalization campaign and is currently co-director of the New Revenue Coalition working to legalize cannabis cafes through the Oregon Legislature. Johnson has co-authored state and local measures in multiple states and has assisted several successful political campaigns. DJC clients include the International Cannabis Business Conference, the Oregon Marijuana Business Conference, Natural Roots, Cannabliss, and numerous medical cannabis cultivators that provide free cannabis to patients in need. DJC assists with licensing, reporting, compliance, public relations, and marketinging, among other tasks, for cannabis and ancillary businesses and campaigns.When he and his co-hosts have time, Anthony hosts the Let's Hash It Out podcast, available here on Weed News, at, Sound Cloud, iTunes, and Stitcher. Anthony's blogs on Weed News are personal and don't necessarily reflect the views of any organization or company.